This wet n wild lip liner is .99 cents and for that price it’s a decent liner. The only colors I could see where very dark and brown or berry, so I picked this one up. The color is willow and it’s not the cutest color at all. It’s kind of a gross brown color, but somehow it semi-works. As far as the formula, it’s pretty good. Doesn’t last if you eat something, but otherwise it lasts a pretty long time.