This is the last makeup remover Neutrogena makes. For a natural product this is the best by far I’ve tried. Now I don’t know exactly how natural it ranks compared to others but it does remove make darn well. All the wipes for some reason were half wetter & half drier. Every single one in the package. The ones more saturated with product removed my makeup well including most of my eye makeup, but the other half didn’t. Some stubborn mascara still lingers but otherwise it’s gone. There was a slight stinging sensation though for about three or so minutes after I was done, so those with ultra sensitive skin beware. However the stinging never happened again after that. Otherwise props to Neutrogena!